Tyrogue’s evolution is determined by its highest appraisal stat value. It’s very simple:

  • Highest ATK -> Hitmonlee
  • Highest DEF -> Hitmonchan
  • Highest STA -> Hitmontop

In case of stats ties, here’s how it works:

  • Tie of two stats -> 50% chance for each
  • Tie of three stats -> 50% chance for Hitmontop, 25% chance for Hitmonlee and Hitmonchan.

Here’s a handy mobile chart, credits go to PixelPoncho!

  • Pascal F

    Got 2 with same STA and DEF, evolved into Hitmonchan both times :/

  • Higher_Ground

    I’d take w/e I could get. I’ve got one Hitmonlee and I can’t remember if it hatched that way or if I caught it – it’s been that long. Haven’t seen any other since and no Tyrogues yet either. Shame too, as it was great for attacking high powered normal types before it fell behind level wise and I don’t have any candy for it.

    • Higher_Ground

      finally hatched a tyrogue! Best stat is HP… but still only have 20 candy, so it’ll be a long time before I get my Hitmonchan (or even Hitmontop at this rate).